Canned Mackerel Melt

Canned Mackerel Melt
Skill Level
Easy
Makes
2 sandwiches
Made with
Roasted Garlic Mackerel from Patagonia Provisions package front

Patagonia Provisions Roasted Garlic Mackerel

$7 - $63

A take on the classic tuna salad and melted-cheese sandwich, this mackerel salad sandwich recipe uses fish that’s responsibly sourced and equally delicious. A mild, surprisingly meaty little fish, our tinned wild Atlantic mackerel is an excellent source of protein and vitamin D, and has over 500 mg of Omega-3s per serving—all without the accumulated toxins associated with large predator fish like tuna and swordfish.

 

For The Mackerel Salad

  • 2 tins Patagonia Provisions Roasted Garlic Mackerel fillets, drained and separated into fat flakes
  • 1 celery stalk, diced small
  • 1 small shallot or 1/4 red onion, diced small
  • About ⅓ cup roughly chopped flat-leaf parsley leaves
  • 1 tbsp. mayonnaise
  • 1 tbsp. lemon juice plus 1 tsp. lemon zest
  • 1 tsp. dijon mustard
  • Salt and pepper

For The Sandwiches

  • 4 slices muenster cheese (3-4 oz.)
  • 6-8 dill pickle chips, drained and patted dry (optional)
  • 4 slices rye bread
  • 3-4 tbsp. salted butter, softened

Putting It All Together

  1. In a medium bowl, gently mix mackerel salad ingredients together.
  2. Heat a nonstick pan over medium heat.
  3. Assemble sandwiches: Lay a cheese slice on a slice of bread. Add 3-4 pickle chips, half of mackerel salad, and another cheese slice; top with bread. Repeat for second sandwich.
  4. Smear tops of sandwiches with half the softened butter. Place sandwiches in pan, buttered side down, then butter the top sides. Cook until golden brown and cheese is melted, about 5 minutes per side.

Love our Roasted Garlic Mackerel? Shop all of our Mackerel Products to discover delicious flavors such as Lemon Caper and Spanish Paprika, or find your favorite with our Patagonia Provisions Mackerel Variety Pack.

What to Serve with Your Mackerel Salad Sandwich

Pair this sandwich alongside breadfruit crackers, cider or kelp pickles. 

 

Mackerel Salad Variations (adapted from The Kitchn)

Wanting to take a different approach than the traditional mackerel and mayonnaise combo? Try these recipe swaps for a fresh take on our Mackerel Sandwich Melt recipe!

  • Use yogurt instead of mayo for a lighter salad.
  • Replace the mayonnaise with the olive oil from the tin for a looser salad.
  • Add diced apples, raisins, or dried fruit to the basic recipe.
  • Add diced fennel, shredded cabbage, diced cucumbers, or any other crunchy vegetable.
  • Add a dash of curry powder, dukkah, harissa, or any other savory spice mix in your cupboard.
  • Stir in chopped fresh herbs.

 

Related Recipes View All

A large white ceramic serving bowl filled with dark green pesto and fusilli sits on a dark wooden table beside a cheese grater with parmesan

Spinach Walnut Pesto Fusilli

Large white serving bowl filled with Patagonia Provisions Organic Kernza Fusilli pasta mixed with vegetables and Lemon Caper Mackerel, on a white table beside glass and bottle of rosé

Fusilli Pasta with Lemon Caper Mackerel

Two bowls of fusilli pasta with vegetables and blue cheese sauce on a patterned cloth

Blue Cheese Fusilli with Zucchini and Red Peppers

Two white ceramic bowls filled with spinach pesto and fusilli pasta and wild sockeye salmon

Spinach Walnut Pesto Fusilli with Salmon

A black cast iron pot filled with Patagonia Provisions Green Lentil Stew on a table beside a bowl of roasted potatoes

Green Lentil Stew

A large wooden serving bowl is overflowing with mixed greens, sliced apples and topped with nuts and Patagonia Provisions savory grains

Grains, Greens and Apple Salad

Hands cutting into slices of toast topped with poached egg and Patagonia Provisions Mackerel

Mackerel and Poached Egg on Toast

A large serving dish of Spaghetti with Puttanesca Sauce beside a bowl full of pasta and a glass of red wine

Spaghetti with Puttanesca Sauce

A grey ceramic dish is filled with salad made with Patagonia Provisions Smoked Mussels, chickpeas, fennel, and vinaigrette

Mussel Salad with Fennel, Chickpeas and Dill Vinaigrette

Patagonia Provisions' Soba Noodles and Wild Sockeye Salmon recipe fills a blue plate on a wooden picnic table

Soba Noodles with Wild Salmon

A bowl of ceviche enhanced with Patagonia Provisions Chile Mango rests on a serving plate surrounded by tortilla chips

Chile Mango Ceviche

A white plate of salad and grilled shrimp rests on a wooden table beside Patagonia Provisions Long Root Ale

Chile Mango Salad

Rockfish seasoned with Patagonia Provisions Aji Molido chile, lime, and butter, cooks beside onion and lemon slices on a grill

Grilled Red Chile Rockfish

A cast iron skillet filled with fried Patagonia Provisions Pink Salmon Hush Puppies, with a small bowl of Chimichurri sauce

Salmon Hush Puppies With Chimichurri Tartar Sauce

A rustic cutting board serves saltines topped with Patagonia Provisions Spanish White Anchovies, olives and fresh parsley, one a white wooden table beside a skillet of anchovies and a glass of beer

Saltines with White Anchovies

Top down view of Patagonia Provisions Fried White Anchovy, Broccoli and Roasted Almond Salad recipe in a ceramic bowl on wooden surface beside deep blue cloth napkin and small bowl of chopped almonds

Fried White Anchovy, Broccoli and Roasted Almond Salad

Patagonia Provisions Lemon Olive Spanish White Anchovies top a tart with olives, onions, red pepper and lemon, served on parchment paper on a wooden board

Lemon Olive Anchovy Tart

White Anchovy Linguine with Toasted Breadcrumbs

White Anchovy Linguine with Toasted Breadcrumbs

A black plate and a white plate, each holding rice balls, some wrapped in a strip of seaweed, with carrot sticks

Smoked Mackerel Rice Balls (Onigiri)

Beet-Pickled deviled eggs on a square metal tray on wooden table

Beet-Pickled Deviled Eggs with Smoked Mackerel

A pot and bowls of spicy red bean chili with toppings and cans of Long Root Wit beer

Spicy Chili for a Crowd

Bowl of Organic Tsampa Soup next to a can of Long Root Ale, small bowls of salt and pepper, and a board of sliced cheese and mini pita breads

Tsampa Soup with Wild Sockeye

Tray of baked sweet potatoes topped with shredded beef and Provisions Barbecue Savory Seeds

Baked Sweet Potatoes with Shredded Beef and BBQ Savory Seeds

A brown bowl of miso noodles, topped with snap peas and Parmesan, next to a small bowl of salted seeds

Miso Parmesan Noodles

Tray of baked sweet potatoes topped with toasted coconut, cilantro, and Provisions Mellow Curry Seeds

Baked Sweet Potatoes with Toasted Coconut and Mellow Curry Seeds

Bowl of kale and carrot salad next to jar of tsampa vinaigrette

Kale and Carrot Salad with Tsampa Vinaigrette

Bowl of Provisions Chimi Crab guacamole on wooden cutting board, beside lime wedges and bowl of salsa

Chimi Crab Guacamole

Bowl of Provisions Carne Adovada with rice and beans on a wooden table with bright red napkin

Provisions Carne Adovada

Person scooping cauliflower from a pan over a campfire onto a plate of couscous

Cauliflower Chickpea Couscous

Illustration of herbs and spinach falling into blender for green smoothie

Dr. Mayer’s Green Smoothie

Avocado toast slices with Patagonia Provisions Wild Salmon, egg, and turmeric

Avocado Toast with Wild Salmon and Turmeric Egg

Creamy salmon dip on toasted seeded bread slices

Wild Salmon Spread

Colorful salad on a blue plate with Mackerel, potatoes, hard-boiled eggs and greens

Mackerel Niçoise Salad

A plate of quinoa with cherry tomatoes, green onions, and a pice of salmon on top

Rainbow Quinoa + Salmon Salad

Salmon and four bean salad on a white plate

Four Bean Salad with Wild Sockeye Salmon